The VAT man says "April Fool!"

Posted on 01 April 2010 by Comments (13)

Spot the April Fool!

Only one of the VAT statements in the list below is untrue.

Which one?

If you think you know which one's a load of rubbish, post a comment below saying which one's not right - and, if you want to be really clever, tell us what's wrong with it. 

First person* to correctly identify the wrong answer and what's wrong with it, wins a bottle of bubbly!

OK, so here is your list.

Remember, only one of these is not 100% true!

  • Millionaire's shortbread, shortbread covered in caramel and chocolate, is zero-rated for VAT, but if you took out the caramel and just had chocolate-covered shortbread, it would be standard-rated for VAT.
  • "Freshly baked" food that just happens to be hot when it leaves the shop, but could just as well be eaten cold (e.g. a freshly baked bread roll from a bakery) is zero-rated, but “hot take-away” food, such as a hot hamburger in a bun, or a hot sausage roll, is standard-rated.
  • Road tunnel and bridge tolls are outside the scope of VAT if they're operated by public authorities, but standard-rated if they're operated by a private company.
  • To zero-rate a sale of goods exported from the UK outside the EU, one condition is that the goods must go overseas within 3 months. But if the goods you're exporting are thoroughbred racehorses, you don't have so long.
  • One of the criteria that HMRC use to determine whether an item is a "biscuit" or a "cake" is what happens when the item goes stale. Biscuits go soft when they're stale, cakes go hard.

Your turn... 

Tell us below which of the above statements is wrong, and why.

If you're the first* to answer this conundrum correctly, a bottle of bubbly will be on its way to you!

* Accountants keep quiet!  Any comments from accountants will be moderated out - you know where to find the answer if you don't already know it! :-)

Over to you...

Kolin, Thu April 01, 2010
The First one is wrong, Both would be standard rate.
Andy Stewart, Thu April 01, 2010
Surely none of these is correct?! The April Fool must be the tax lawyer(s) who made up these rules.
Stuart Jones, Thu April 01, 2010
[Accountant answers have been edited]
Last Edit: April 01, 2010, 10:24:36 by olly  
Dennis Howlett, Thu April 01, 2010
I'm only answering that if it is Veuve Clicquot - 1990 Reserve (of course)
Charles Verrier, Thu April 01, 2010
I'm going with the second to last [edited]
Last Edit: April 01, 2010, 11:09:33 by olly  
olly, Thu April 01, 2010
I think we should have clarified that this isn't a question for accountants, so we're editing the responses.

Sorry!
Charles Verrier, Thu April 01, 2010
Oh wait - the shortbread thing was collateral damage from the M&S case against HMRC for their teacakes VAT status.

You do wonder if all the lawyers on that case ever took a step back from debating teacakes and flapjacks and thought "What am I doing with my life?"
Suzanne, Thu April 01, 2010
It's the second one! Of course you can eat cold sausage rolls just like a cold bread roll, just not as tasty ;-)
Cole, Thu April 01, 2010
Ha! Opting for the last one. I know my biscuit-fu, now where's my can of Irn Bru?

Cole
Charles Verrier, Thu April 01, 2010
Olly, stop editing me! I'm not an accountant, I just hang around with them a lot!
Mike Wilson, Thu April 01, 2010
I'm pretty sure it's the first one although I am not an accountant! The chocolate coating means it's a cake and not a biscuit and thus is subject to VAT. If it didn't have the chocolate on top (nor the caramel) it would just be treated as a biscuit and no subject to VAT.

e.g. digestives versus chocolate coated digestives.
emily, Thu April 08, 2010
Hi folks.

The correct answer was... point 4!

And the wrong bit is that you get longer than 3 months for exporting racehorses... not shorter!

The rest of the points are all true. No, honest :-)

Thank you to all who responded!

Emily
Mike Wilson, Mon April 12, 2010
Hi Emily,

I really thought I had that one in the bag :) Thanks for the advice; you really do learn something new every day!
(Comments closed)

Recent Posts

Twitter Love

  • Thanks to @freeagent I will never need to use the crappy HMRC payroll software come April.

  • all sorted and ready for PAYE RTI thanks to @freeagent awesomeness.

  • The latest reason why I continue to love @freeagent http://t.co/nfYqVJDfa4 HMRC chucks a stress out at businesses, FreeAgent bats it away!

  • Those folks @freeagent do it right. The confirmation mail includes important information: http://t.co/HCHIvgjpI0

  • @NickClement @freeagent its excellent for invoicing, very flexible & easy - esp billable time by task from timeslips-capture the revenue!

Follow:

Escape spreadsheet hell with FreeAgent.

Try FreeAgent for Free